What Does Malpractice Insurance Cost?
- Malpractice insurance isn’t optional for medical professionals risking lawsuits whenever care doesn’t go as planned. Over the past decade, premiums have steadily risen—and in many cases, spiked—making it more critical than ever to understand who pays what and why.
Rising Premium Trends Nationwide
According to the American Medical Association, nearly half of malpractice premiums increased from 2023 to 2024—a sharp jump from just 14% in 2018. This indicates a broader market squeeze, with 16 states seeing hikes of 10% or more. Additional surveys by MGMA confirm this trend: 68% of medical groups reported higher premiums since 2022, with an average increase of 11%.
How Much Physicians Pay
While premiums vary by specialty and location, here’s a quick snapshot:
- Average physicians spend about $7,500 annually, or roughly 3.2% of their income.
- However, high-risk specialties like OB/GYN and surgery can see rates between $30,000–$50,000+ yearly.
- Some OB/GYNs in New York pay upwards of $226,000 annually.
Nurses & Other Clinical Staff
Premiums for nurses are significantly lower than for physicians but still important:
- Many insurance firms note that neonatal, critical-care, and OB nurses face the most frequent claims.
- Despite typically lower expectations, nurses operating in high-risk units should still expect to invest in malpractice coverage.
Nurse Practitioners and Students
- Nurse Practitioners also carry liability risks proportionate to their advanced responsibilities and training. While their premiums are typically in the low thousands annually—lower than most physicians—they still need reliable coverage for peace of mind and professional protection.
- Clinical students generally pay much lower premiums, but coverage provides essential protection during training and internships.
Key Factors Driving Costs
- Specialty Risk: High-liability fields like surgery or obstetrics naturally carry higher premiums
- Geographic Location: State laws, tort ceilings, and jury damages vary widely. Places like New York, Pennsylvania, and Florida sit at the high end .
- Claims Trends: Increasing “nuclear verdicts” (multi-million-dollar awards) are pressuring insurers and shrinking capacity.
- Type & Amount of Coverage: Higher policy limits and preference for occurrence-based coverage increase premium costs.
What You Can Expect in 2025
The industry is bracing for continued rate increases—with some predictions showing annual premium growth between 5–15%. As capacity tightens, professionals may find limited options or attached caveats with policies.
Why Carrying Malpractice Insurance Is Non-Negotiable
While premiums can feel steep—especially during premium spikes—skimping on coverage can be a career-ending mistake:
- Legal Risks: One lawsuit could cost more than a decade of insurance premiums.
- Coverage Gaps: Even if an employer covers you, some policies exclude tail, prior acts, or certain claim types.
- Peace of Mind: You can focus on patient care instead of worrying about legal liabilities.
Malpractice insurance premiums are rising—steadily and significantly—across all healthcare roles. Physicians in high-risk specialties and high-liability states face the steepest costs. Despite the expense, coverage remains essential protection against unpredictable—but potentially devastating—legal challenges.
NOW has streamlined the insurance underwriting process to lower premium costs for allied health professionals—including nurses and nurse practitioners.
Many find our rates are up to 30% lower than their current insurance provider. Get a personalized quote in under 3 minutes by entering your profession and location information.
- Average physicians spend about $7,500 annually, or roughly 3.2% of their income.
